BAQIS-Affiliated Team Demonstrates a Thorium-229 Nuclear Clock
2026/10/08
Advances in laser technology, crystal growth and optical readout establish an operating nuclear frequency reference
A research team led by Shiqian Ding, an Adjunct Research Professor at the Beijing Academy of Quantum Information Sciences (BAQIS) and Associate Professor of Physics at Tsinghua University, has demonstrated a thorium-229 nuclear clock. Working with partner institutions across China, the team combined its independently developed continuous-wave vacuum-ultraviolet laser at 148 nanometers with thorium-229-doped calcium fluoride crystals. By measuring nuclear absorption and continuously locking the laser frequency to the nuclear transition, the researchers established an operating nuclear frequency reference.
The study, “A nuclear clock synchronized to 229Th,” was published online in Nature on October 7, 2026. Together with independent work completed at nearly the same time by a European team, it marks the realization of the first operating thorium-229 nuclear clocks.
Atomic microwave clocks underpin today’s timekeeping infrastructure, while atomic optical clocks provide the highest measurement precision. Both use transitions involving electrons as their frequency references. A nuclear clock instead uses a transition within the atomic nucleus. Because nuclei are much smaller than atoms, nuclear transitions can be less sensitive to certain external electromagnetic perturbations, offering a potential route to more accurate time and frequency standards.
Solid-state nuclear clocks also offer prospects for compact and robust devices: large numbers of nuclei can be embedded in a millimeter-scale crystal and interrogated together. With further development, these systems could serve applications in satellite navigation, deep-space exploration and communications. Although nuclear clocks do not yet outperform the best atomic optical clocks, their successful operation establishes a new approach to precision timekeeping.
Their significance extends beyond clocks. The thorium-229 transition is expected to have enhanced sensitivity to changes in certain fundamental constants. Comparisons between nuclear and atomic clocks could therefore reveal signatures of new physics. Optical access to this transition also opens opportunities to extend precision measurement and quantum control from electronic states to nuclear states.
Most nuclear transitions require energies far beyond those accessible with conventional lasers. Thorium-229 is exceptional: its lowest excited nuclear state lies only about 8.4 electronvolts above the ground state, corresponding to a wavelength of approximately 148 nanometers. Earlier experiments used pulsed laser sources to excite and measure this transition. However, the lack of a suitable continuous-wave source remained a central obstacle to nuclear clock development.
Ding’s team addressed this challenge by developing the world’s first continuous-wave laser at 148 nanometers. Using four-wave mixing in cadmium vapor, the researchers generated narrow-linewidth vacuum-ultraviolet light and demonstrated that the frequency-conversion process introduced no observable additional phase noise within the sensitivity of their measurements. The result showed that the coherence of ultrastable input lasers could be transferred into this demanding spectral region. The laser work was published in Nature in February 2026.
For the nuclear clock experiment, the team subsequently increased the laser power to approximately 10 microwatts, with an estimated linewidth below one hertz. This combination of power and spectral purity provided a critical tool for detecting the weak nuclear response and stabilizing the laser to it.
A second challenge was the nuclear material itself. Thorium-229 is exceptionally scarce, with only 1.4 micrograms available to the team. At the outset, the concentration required to obtain a sufficiently strong signal was not established for the experimental system. Concentrating the available isotope into a small crystal offered a way to increase the signal, but also imposed demanding requirements on crystal growth and optical quality.
Through collaboration among several Chinese institutions, the researchers developed a small-volume crystal-growth approach. Using the entire 1.4-microgram supply in a single growth run, they successfully produced a high-quality, millimeter-scale thorium-doped calcium fluoride crystal. With essentially no material available for a second attempt, the successful growth was a decisive step in the experiment.
With the laser and crystals in place, the next task was to read the nuclear signal rapidly enough to support clock operation. Earlier nuclear spectroscopy experiments relied primarily on fluorescence detection. The long lifetime of the excited nuclear state, however, makes fluorescence-based measurement cycles slow. Direct absorption spectroscopy offers a faster approach by measuring the small reduction in laser intensity as light passes through the crystal.
The team developed a sensitive absorption readout capable of resolving this weak nuclear response. A phototube operated in direct-photocurrent mode accommodated substantially higher optical power than conventional photomultiplier readout under the experimental conditions. Low-noise amplification and modulation-based detection then enabled the researchers to extract the nuclear signal from the background and determine the laser’s frequency error.
The researchers selected a resolved nuclear transition combining a narrow linewidth with weak temperature sensitivity. During each interrogation cycle, they measured the laser’s frequency offset from the nuclear resonance and used that information to correct the laser frequency through a feedback loop. This kept the laser locked to the nuclear transition over successive cycles.
The clock achieved a short-term fractional frequency instability of 5 × 10-13 at one second, with further averaging reaching the 10-15 level. This world-leading short-term stability for a nuclear clock reflects the combined advances in the laser source, crystal preparation and optical readout.
The team also investigated a crucial question for solid-state clocks: whether independently prepared crystals provide reproducible nuclear frequencies. Unlike isolated atoms or ions, nuclei embedded in solids experience local environments that may depend on growth conditions, dopant concentration and defects.
The researchers compared two crystals grown by different methods, with different thorium concentrations and optical properties. One contained visible bubbles. Despite these differences, the measured clock-transition frequencies agreed at the 10-13 level. Both measurements were also consistent, within their uncertainties, with earlier results from the JILA team in the United States.
These comparisons directly address whether different solid-state samples can provide a reproducible nuclear frequency reference. They support the prospect of accurate solid-state nuclear clocks and provide an experimental route toward identifying and controlling material-dependent frequency shifts.
Together, these advances establish a complete experimental capability spanning the core laser source, nuclear-clock crystals, precision spectroscopy and closed-loop operation.
Ding also received the inaugural 2026 World Laureates Foundation Prize for Young Scientists. The award recognized his “pioneering experimental results in continuous-wave vacuum ultraviolet lasers, the thorium-229 nuclear clock, and nuclear quantum precision measurements.”
Reflecting on the achievement, Ding described building on decades of work by the international scientific community as a humbling experience. He paid tribute to the researchers whose discoveries established the unusual properties of thorium-229, proposed the nuclear-clock concept, and made direct laser excitation and precision nuclear spectroscopy possible. He also emphasized that the present work depended on sustained institutional support and collaboration across disciplines.
Crystal development was a particularly intensive collaborative effort. The Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics, the Shanghai Institute of Ceramics and the Shanghai Institute of Applied Physics of the Chinese Academy of Sciences worked with the Tsinghua team on the preparation and characterization of thorium-229-doped calcium fluoride crystals.
Xibo Zhang’s team at Peking University and Yige Lin’s team at the National Institute of Metrology, China, provided important support in ultrastable lasers, frequency metrology and precision measurement. At Tsinghua University, Professors Yuxiang Mo and Li You contributed expertise and resources during the development of the continuous-wave vacuum-ultraviolet source. Xuegang Liu’s team at Tsinghua’s Institute of Nuclear and New Energy Technology supported the experimental infrastructure required for thorium-229 research.
The team acknowledges the long-term support of Tsinghua University and its Department of Physics, BAQIS, and Tsinghua’s Institute of Nuclear and New Energy Technology.
The corresponding authors are Shiqian Ding of BAQIS and Tsinghua University, Liangbi Su of the Shanghai Institute of Ceramics, Yin Hang of the Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics, and Wenhao Bu, a postdoctoral researcher at BAQIS.
The co-first authors are Beichen Huang, Gaowei Yan and Qi Xiao, who entered Tsinghua University’s doctoral program in physics in 2022, 2024 and 2025, respectively; Wenhao Bu of BAQIS; Chengchun Zhao of the Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics; Zhen Zhang of the Shanghai Institute of Ceramics; and Chao Yan of the Shanghai Institute of Applied Physics.The research received support from Tsinghua University’s Dushi Program and BAQIS, together with funding from national and local research programs.
Paper: Beichen Huang et al., “A nuclear clock synchronized to 229Th,” Nature 658, 903–908 (2026).
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11122-1
中文
Email
QCloud
Log in
